Collection: Butt Plugs

What is a butt plug? A butt plug (aka an anal plug) is a short toy that slips into the bum to provide pleasure from all of the orgasmic nerves found in the anal region. Unlike most other sex toys out there, a butt plug is designed to slip into the body and then be left alone. While you'd likely want to thrust a dildo or move a gspot vibrator around, butt plugs are specifically designed to become stationary toys that add constant sensation while you enjoy other things - like masturbation or even household chores!

Now sure how to find the best butt plug for your first? We're here to help! Before anything else, you need to pay attention to size - especially the diameter. (We have a "diameter" filter here to help you easily narrow down your choices!) Essentially, your butt can only stretch so far - especially if you're new to anal sex. Trying to stretch past that point is what causes injury, and we don't want that! Instead, stick with butt plugs that are well-within your current anal experience.

Not sure what anal plug is the best fit for your current experience? Next time you're using your fingers on yourself, keep a tape measure handy. Slide them in as far as is comfortable with lube, and make a note where that spots was on your fingers. Remove your fingers and measure the diameter of that spot. Now you have a general idea of what size of butt plug you should start with! (Of course, anal stretching is something people love to do as well, and if you're looking for butt plugs for anal sex, we highly recommend our anal training kit to use training butt plugs for anal sex.)

You just happen to have found yourself on the page that includes our curated selection of butt plugs. While you're here, don't forget to check out some of our favorite offerings including a jewel butt plug, a thrusting butt plug, a weighted butt plug, a vibrating butt plug, a butt plug tail, a public butt plug, an app controlled butt plug, a remote control butt plug, a long distance butt plug, a music butt plug, a stainless steel butt plug, an electrosex butt plug, a beginner butt plug, and an anal training kit. We have a lot for you to check out, so enjoy shopping at Kinkly Shop - and feel free to reach out to us if you need any answers about butt plugs!

(You may also have found yourself here by searching "buttplug"!)

Showing 132 products

Save $5.01
OxBalls Pighole 3OxBalls Pighole 3
Oxballs OxBalls Pighole 3
$96.00 $90.99
Save $3.01
Biird AniiBiird Anii
Biird Biird Anii
$39.00 $35.99
Save $7
Open RosesOpen Roses
Strap-On-Me Open Roses
$28.99 $21.99
Save $3
Doxy SmoothDoxy Smooth
Doxy Doxy Smooth
$59.99 $56.99
Save $7.96
Crystal Delights Magnetic Bunny TailCrystal Delights Magnetic Bunny Tail
Save $13.01
The Fort Troff Kum Keeper shown with the stopper plug removed | KinklyThe Fort Troff Kum Keeper shown from the side with the plug inserted in it | Kinkly
Doc Johnson Fort Troff Kum Keeper
$33.00 $19.99
Save $10.11
248143826.jpg248143823.jpg
Doc Johnson A Play Groovy
$22.10 $11.99
Mood Naughty 2 in Black | KinklyThe Mood Naughty 2 in Blue | Kinkly
Doc Johnson Mood Naughty 2
$24.49
Save $12.39
Naughty 1 Anal Trainer Set in Pink | KinklyNaughty 1 Anal Trainer Set in Black | Kinkly
Doc Johnson Naughty 1 Anal Trainer Set
$36.38 $23.99
Save $11.81
Crystal Jellies Anal Initiation Kit in Purple | Kinkly ShopCrystal Jellies Anal Initiation Kit in Pink | Kinkly Shop
Save $15.21
202278826.jpg259542465.jpg
Save $10.07
195359003.jpg253480639.jpg
XR Brands Tailz Grey Fox Tail Anal Plug
$62.06 $51.99
Save $13.41
195359001.jpg195359002.jpg
Save $1.51
228483933.jpg287269017.jpg
OhMiBod OhMiBod Lovelife Dare
$29.00 $27.49
Save $3.84
287274644.jpgBooty Sparks Pink Gem
XR Brands Booty Sparks Pink Gem
$16.33 $12.49

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Recently viewed